Beyond the 9-to-5: Navigating Chronic Pain with a Fluctuating Capacity

By Meredith Hutton, owner of meredithhutton79 Chronic Creative Lifestyle Management, where "Empathy Leads, Purpose Guides, and Resilience Builds. Turn Your Pain Into Purpose, and Your Purpose Into Power."

The rigid structure of the traditional workweek—five days, nine-to-five—is a poor fit for many. For those living with chronic pain, it can be downright impossible. I have so much respect for people who still work even though they are struggling with chronic pain. Many have no choice but to work, and that’s a hard reality to live. The reality of chronic pain is not a straight line of consistent symptoms. It’s not something that has a set schedule. It's a series of unpredictable peaks and troughs, where one day you might feel ready to tackle the world, and the next, simply getting out of bed is a monumental effort. This is the essence of fluctuating capacity, and understanding how to design your workweek around it is key to not only managing your pain but also thriving in your professional life. 

Why Fluctuating Capacity Is a Pain Warrior's Reality

Fluctuating capacity is the daily, and sometimes even hourly, variation in a person's physical and mental ability to perform tasks. For pain warriors, it's a constant companion. A 'good day' might mean your pain is at a manageable level (say, a 4 or 5 out of 10) and your energy is high. You can concentrate, move around with relative ease, and be productive. A 'bad day' might see your pain spike to an 8 or 9 out of 10, accompanied by debilitating fatigue, brain fog, and muscle weakness. On such a day, even the simplest tasks feel overwhelming. The constant up and down and unpredictable nature of fluctuating capacity, makes it hard to work a regular set of hours each day. It makes it hard to work at all. But not everyone has the option to go on some sort of disability pension. 

This fluctuation is a core reality of conditions like Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS), like I have, as well as fibromyalgia, rheumatoid arthritis, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), and chronic migraines. It’s not about being lazy or unmotivated; it's a physiological response to the underlying condition. Ignoring it and trying to push through often leads to a 'pain flare'—a period of intensified symptoms that can last for days or even weeks, ultimately derailing your progress and making it harder to work in the long run. This is a common cycle for pain warriors to find themselves in. We put so much pressure on ourselves to be productive and useful, whether we are working outside the home, or not, that on good days we often ignore the signals our body is sending telling us to take a rest, or to slow down, because we feel like we need to play catch up. This usually causes a pain flare, leaving pain warriors and spoonies feeling like they’ve lost the progress they’ve worked so hard to make. Once the pain flare ends, we say we won’t, but we do it all over again. The demands of work, and our responsibilities at home, don’t always align with our chronic pain, leaving us without many reasonable choices other than pushing through, if we want to keep our job. 

The Impact of Fluctuating Capacity on Work

The traditional work model doesn’t account for this reality. When I fell, I was working shift work as a 911 operator and was almost finished my training to become a police dispatcher. Within a few months it was obvious I could no longer work and despite my best efforts, I found myself unemployed. My body and mind just couldn’t keep up. 

The realities of pain warriors trying to force a consistent 40-hour workweek on a fluctuating body often leads to:

1. The "Boom and Bust" Cycle: This is a classic pattern where you overexert yourself on a 'good day' to make up for lost time (the “boom”), only to crash the next day (the 'bust'), leading to more pain, fatigue, and an inability to work. This cycle is both physically and mentally draining. For example, a person with chronic back pain might feel great on a Monday, work 10 hours straight, and then spend the next two days in bed, unable to move due to the severe pain from overdoing it. It’s a pattern that even though most of us are aware we have to pace ourselves, and take rests, self care, etc. it doesn’t always line up to the realities of our daily commitments, leaving us stuck in this cycle. 
2. Increased Stress and Anxiety: The constant worry about whether you'll be able to perform your job on any given day creates significant mental distress. This stress can, in turn, exacerbate pain symptoms, creating a vicious feedback loop. We don’t always realize how much stress we have when we are living in a constant state of high stress, and don’t realize how much that stress actually impacts our pain, until we no longer feel that high level of stress and our bodies calm down. 
3. Feeling of Inadequacy: This is already a thing for most of us that suffer with chronic pain, feeling worthy or good enough, but when you have to work and can't perform at a consistent level, it's easy to further internalize the idea that you're not good enough or not a reliable person or employee. This can damage self-esteem and lead to depression. 

Coping Strategies: Designing Your Flexible Week

The solution lies in embracing your fluctuating capacity and designing a workweek that works with your body, not against it. This isn't just about asking for accommodations; it's about a fundamental shift in mindset and strategy. Living with chronic pain means you have to strategically allot your time and energy each day. You have to carefully weigh the consequences of doing this, how much recovery time you’ll need if you do that. Living with persistent pain means If you don’t manage your energy strategically, you’ll find yourself on the quick path to burnout. 

1. Pacing, Not Pushing: Pacing is the most crucial skill a pain warrior can learn. Instead of working until you hit a wall, you break down tasks and work in short, manageable bursts, followed by rest periods. Think of it like interval training for your work. I personally like to use the popular and fun Pomodoro focus app Forest, which can be found in the App Store and Google Play. The premise of Pomodoro focus timers are that you work for a set amount of time, usually 25 minutes, then take a short break. After you do that 4 times you take a longer break. 
   • Example: As mentioned above, instead of sitting at your desk for three hours to write a report, you work for 25 minutes, take a 5-10 minute break to stretch or lie down, and then return to the task. This prevents the 'bust' and helps maintain a more consistent level of productivity throughout the day and week.
2. Prioritize and Plan for the Peaks and Troughs: Accept that some days will be more productive than others. Use your 'good days' for high-concentration, high-energy tasks like important meetings or complex problem-solving. Use your 'bad days' for lighter tasks that require less mental or physical effort, like answering emails, organizing files, or watching a training video. By accepting that there will be peaks and troughs, you can organize your weeks accordingly to work with the ebbs and flows of chronic pain management. A good idea would be to track your energy and how work impacts it, so you can hopefully pick up on any patterns that will help you in planning your work week. 
   • Example: You might schedule a presentation for a Thursday, knowing that's typically your strongest day of the week. You'd avoid scheduling it on a Monday morning, which is often a low-energy day after a weekend of rest and re-entry into the work week. 
3. Communicate with Your Employer: Transparency is key. You don't need to overshare personal details, but a conversation about your need for flexibility can open up possibilities. Discuss working from home, flexible hours, or a reduced workload. Frame it in terms of your increased efficiency and productivity, not as a limitation. Now-a-days it’s not uncommon for those with chronic pain or other invisible disabilities, to ask for and receive certain accommodations in their places of work. 
   • Example: "I've found that my productivity is highest when I can manage my work hours around my energy levels. Could we explore a flexible schedule where I might work fewer hours on some days and more on others, as long as I meet my project deadlines?"
4. Embrace Non-Traditional Work Structures:
   • Async Work: This is work that doesn't require everyone to be online at the same time. It's a perfect fit for fluctuating capacity. You can answer a colleague's question at 11 pm when you have a burst of energy, and they can respond in the morning.
   • Project-Based Work: Focusing on a project with a set deadline, rather than a rigid weekly schedule, can be incredibly freeing. You can work intensely when you're able and rest when you need to, as long as the project is completed by the deadline. If you go this route, you really have to be on top of time blindness and cramming at the last minute to get it done. Like many who suffer from chronic pain, this is a trap I fall into when I think I have lots of time. 

Pros of Embracing a Flexible Work Model with Fluctuating Capacity

The decision to adopt a flexible work model is a strategic move that fundamentally shifts the relationship between your chronic pain and your professional life. It's not just a set of accommodations; it's a proactive approach to well-being that yields significant benefits. Let's delve deeper into the advantages:

1. Improved Health: A Proactive Shield Against Pain Flares

The traditional work structure often forces people with chronic pain to push beyond their limits, leading to a constant state of physiological stress. This is where the concept of "working with your body's natural rhythms" becomes a powerful tool.

• Pain Flares as a Warning System: Imagine your body's energy as a finite resource, like a battery. On a "good day," the battery might be at 80%, but on a "bad day," it could be as low as 30%. A rigid 9-to-5 schedule demands a consistent output of 100%, regardless of your battery level. This constant over-drafting leads to a "pain flare," which is essentially your body's alarm system screaming that you've pushed too far. A flare isn't just a temporary increase in pain; it's an inflammatory cascade that can take days or weeks to settle down, often causing widespread pain, fatigue, and other debilitating symptoms.
• The Power of Pacing: A flexible model allows you to pace yourself. By working in short, focused bursts followed by intentional rest, you never deplete your "battery" to a critical level. For example, instead of enduring a long meeting that leaves you drained and in pain, you can suggest shorter meetings or ask for a break halfway through. This proactive self-management prevents the severe pain, fatigue, and burnout that result from overexertion, leading to fewer and less severe flares over time. The result is a more stable physical state and a greater sense of control.

2. Sustained Productivity: Escaping the "Boom and Bust" Trap

The "boom and bust" cycle is the nemesis of anyone with a fluctuating capacity. It's a pattern of overworking on high-energy days (the "boom") and then completely crashing on the following days (the "bust"), resulting in zero or minimal output.

• Maximizing Output, Minimizing Waste: A flexible model allows you to break this cycle by shifting the focus from hours worked to output produced. Instead of feeling guilty for taking a rest day, you recognize it as a strategic investment. You know that by resting today, you are preventing a bigger "bust" tomorrow. This strategic rest ensures that your productive days are truly productive, and your low-energy days are not completely wasted.
• Example in Practice: Consider a writer with chronic migraines. In a traditional job, she might have to power through a migraine to meet a deadline, resulting in low-quality work and a severe post-migraine crash. In a flexible model, she can use her "good days" to write when her mind is clear and sharp, and her "bad days" to handle administrative tasks or rest completely. Over the course of a month, the total word count is likely to be much higher and of better quality than if she had attempted to work every single day, regardless of her health. This approach replaces sporadic bursts of high-intensity work with a more even, sustainable flow of productivity.

3. Increased Job Satisfaction: Less Stress, More Control

Chronic pain and the stress of a rigid work schedule are a toxic combination. The constant pressure to perform can lead to anxiety, frustration, and a pervasive feeling of being out of control.

• Reducing Cognitive Burden: A flexible model reduces a significant cognitive burden. Instead of constantly worrying, "Will I be able to work tomorrow?" you can focus on the tasks at hand. You are no longer fighting your body; you are collaborating with it. This shift from a state of conflict to a state of cooperation is incredibly liberating.
• A Feeling of Empowerment: When you have the autonomy to manage your own schedule, you feel empowered. You are an active participant in your career, not a victim of your illness. This sense of control is directly linked to higher job satisfaction. When you can prioritize your health appointments, take breaks when you need them, and work when you feel your best, you are more engaged, more motivated, and ultimately, happier in your role.

4. Better Quality of Life: Integrating Work and Well-Being

The most profound benefit of a flexible work model is its impact on your overall quality of life. For someone with a chronic condition, work can't be an isolated part of life; it must be integrated with the demands of managing your health.

• Prioritizing Non-Work Essentials: A flexible schedule allows you to attend crucial medical appointments, physical therapy sessions, or mental health counseling without the stress of having to take a sick day or make up hours. These appointments are not just "nice to have"; they are essential for your well-being and your ability to work at all.
• Creating Space for Self-Care: Self-care for a pain warrior is not a luxury; it is a necessity. This includes things like gentle exercise, stretching, mindfulness, or simply lying down in a dark room during a pain spike. A flexible model allows you to build these non-negotiable self-care activities into your day, ensuring that you are consistently taking care of your body and mind. This proactive care prevents a downward spiral of pain and fatigue, allowing you to live a more balanced and fulfilling life beyond just your career.

Cons of a Flexible Work Model with Fluctuating Capacity

While a flexible work model offers significant benefits, it's not without its challenges. Understanding these potential drawbacks beforehand can help you prepare for them, ensuring that this approach is sustainable and successful in the long run.

1. Communication Challenges

Working on a flexible schedule, especially an asynchronous one, can create friction when a team is not set up to handle it. The 9-to-5 workday is built on the assumption that everyone is available at the same time for meetings, impromptu discussions, and quick questions.

• Siloed Information: When you and your colleagues are not online at the same time, information can get stuck. A colleague might have a quick question that halts their progress until you are available to answer it. This can cause frustration and delays, especially if the team is used to a culture of instant responses.
• Difficulty with Collaboration: Collaborative tasks, such as brainstorming or editing documents together, can be difficult to coordinate. A colleague might get to a point in the project where they need your input, but since you are offline, they must wait. This can slow down the entire team's workflow and create a sense of disconnect.
• The "Urgency" Myth: Many workplaces operate with a high sense of urgency, where every request feels like an emergency. A flexible schedule challenges this notion, and you may face pressure to be available even when you are not scheduled to work. It requires clear boundaries and a strong commitment from both you and your team to establish new communication norms.

2. The Need for Self-Discipline

The freedom of a flexible schedule is a double-edged sword. Without the external structure of a traditional office, you become entirely responsible for managing your time, energy, and productivity.

• Avoiding Procrastination: When you have the autonomy to work when you feel your best, it can be tempting to push off tasks until a "better day." This can lead to a backlog of work and increased stress as deadlines approach. It requires a high level of self-awareness to recognize when you are genuinely having a low-capacity day versus when you are procrastinating.
• Maintaining Boundaries: It can be difficult to switch off. The flexibility that allows you to work at odd hours also makes it easy for work to bleed into your personal time. This can lead to burnout if you are not disciplined about setting clear boundaries and taking intentional breaks. The responsibility to not overwork falls entirely on your shoulders.
• Staying Accountable: There is no manager or colleague watching your every move. You are responsible for ensuring your work is completed on time and to a high standard. This requires a high level of personal accountability and a clear understanding of your goals and deadlines.

3. Potential for Misunderstanding

Chronic pain is often an invisible illness, and the concept of fluctuating capacity can be difficult for others to grasp. This can lead to misconceptions and a lack of empathy from colleagues and employers.

• The "Looks Fine" Fallacy: You may appear perfectly healthy on a "good day," which can make it hard for others to understand why you need flexibility on a "bad day." This can lead to skepticism and the hurtful assumption that you are using your health as an excuse.
• Feeling Like You're Not "Pulling Your Weight": When colleagues see you working fewer hours on some days, they might not understand that you are making up for it on others. This can lead to resentment or a feeling that you are not contributing equally to the team's success.
• Managerial Skepticism: Some managers are used to a model of in-person, visible work and may be hesitant to embrace a flexible schedule. They might worry about their ability to manage a team they can't see, or they may be concerned about setting a precedent that others will want to follow. This requires you to be a strong advocate for yourself and clearly demonstrate the value of your work.

A Deeper Dive into Self-Assessment: Building Your Case for a Flexible Work Model

Making the switch to a flexible work model isn't just about asking for a change; it's about building a strong, data-driven case for why it will benefit both you and your employer. This is where a thorough self-assessment becomes your most valuable tool.

1. Tracking Your Patterns: The Power of Personal Data

You can't manage what you don't measure. Before you propose any changes, you need to understand your unique rhythm. This isn't just about knowing you have good days and bad days; it's about identifying the specific patterns and triggers that define them.

• The Daily and Weekly Audit: For at least two weeks, keep a detailed log. Note your pain levels on a scale of 1 to 10. Record your energy levels (e.g., high, medium, low). Track your mental clarity and physical capacity. Most importantly, document what tasks you completed and how long they took.
  • Example: You might find a clear pattern: "Mondays and Tuesdays are often low-energy and high-pain days, but my brain fog lifts around 2 PM. Thursdays and Fridays are consistently my most productive days, with a burst of high energy in the morning." This data allows you to say, "I'm at my best for strategic tasks on Thursday mornings, so I'd like to schedule our team's planning meeting then."
• Identify Triggers and Predictors: Your tracking journal can help you uncover connections. For instance, you might notice that your pain spikes after a long meeting or a specific type of task. This information is crucial for not just proposing a new schedule but also for managing your condition. For instance, if you know that sitting for more than 45 minutes causes a flare, you can build in standing or stretching breaks to your proposed schedule.

2. Identifying Your Non-Negotiables: Aligning Your Career with Your Health

A flexible work model is a tool to achieve a goal, but you have to know what that goal is. What is the fundamental purpose of your work in your life?

• Financial Stability: Is income your primary motivator? If so, your proposal must focus on how a flexible model will maintain or even increase your output, securing your financial well-being and proving your value to the company.
• Sense of Purpose: Do you work for the fulfillment of the job itself? If so, your proposal should emphasize how flexibility will allow you to do your best work consistently, preventing burnout and keeping you engaged with your tasks.
• Social Connection: Is working in a team or with the public a key part of your job satisfaction? If so, your proposal can include a mix of remote work and in-office time to ensure you maintain those valuable social connections while still honoring your health needs. For instance, you could propose working remotely on your low-energy days but coming into the office on your most productive days to collaborate in person.

3. Creating a Concrete Proposal: The Business Case for Flexibility

You are not asking for a favor; you are presenting a business solution. Your proposal should be clear, concise, and focused on how this change will benefit the company.

• Focus on Outcomes, Not Hours: Instead of saying, "I can't work 9 to 5," say, "I am proposing a flexible schedule that will allow me to be more reliable and productive." Your goal is to show that you will still meet or exceed your objectives.
• Highlight the Benefits to the Company:
  • Increased Productivity: Explain how working when you are most focused and energetic will lead to higher-quality work and a greater output of completed tasks.
  • Improved Reliability: By proactively managing your pain and avoiding the "boom and bust" cycle, you will be a more reliable employee who is less likely to miss work due to a flare-up.
  • Higher Retention: Show that a company that supports its employees' health is a place people want to stay. Your proposal can demonstrate your long-term commitment to the company.
• Include a Trial Period: A good proposal often includes a trial period. Suggest a 30- or 60-day trial to demonstrate that your new schedule works for both you and the team. This reduces the risk for your employer and gives you a chance to prove your model's success.

The final step is to remember that this process is a marathon. It's about a fundamental shift in how you approach your work and your health. By doing your homework and building a strong, data-backed case, you're not just asking for a change—you're proving why it's the smartest move for everyone involved.

Living and working with chronic pain is a long game, not a short one. By accepting the reality of fluctuating capacity and designing a flexible work life, you can move from a state of constant struggle to one of sustainable success and well-being. It's not about working less; it's about working smarter, and in a way that honors your body's unique needs.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

You don't have to manage your chronic pain journey alone. Join our community of pain warriors by signing up for my newsletter on the home page or below any blog post on my website https://meredithhutton79.com/meredithhutton79. As a welcome gift, I'll send you two complimentary pain-tracking pages and a 200-page household planner to help ease your mental load.

For more resources, browse my collection of chronic pain-themed trackers, planners, and journals at my shop: https://meredithhutton79.com/shop